I make a point to completely turn off my phone when I enter a cinema. Not only on silent mode – all the way off. I share this not because I'm superior, or to suggest that the specter of a classic director will appear to congratulate me. I view it as a simple small luxuries: for a minimum of ninety minutes, I am entirely unreachable. I maintain my phone off throughout the closing credits as well. It strikes me as indulgent to stay put as the audience slowly filter out, bathed in the light of the scrolling names.
And, increasingly, by the glow of the cataloguing app.
More than millions of users use Letterboxd, a cinema-tracking app. Similar to A24, it has transformed into a marker for a particular kind of aficionado who promotes fresh cinema and delights in unearthing old classics. Patrons rate and review films, and the wittiest or most illuminating reviews ascend to the top, encouraging film lovers to craft thoughtful responses.
"Unless I articulate my impressions quickly after the credits roll, my write-ups are significantly less clear and eloquent," remarked a student.
In a recent visit to the theater, the end titles had just begun before the patron seated in front of me began typing his thoughts. Nearby, a pair lingered, looking down, recording their respective thoughts.
The legendary film-maker David Lynch once offered guidance: record every spark of inspiration the very second it occurs to you. If you don't, it could slip your mind, and, as he phrased it: "Forgetting a valuable thought, you feel like you could commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to budding directors, this mindset applies to the post-film ritual.
One young man, a 20-year-old student in New York, without fail drafts his assessments from his theater seat.
"If I don't get my thoughts out promptly once the movie ends, my reviews are significantly less coherent and articulate," he explained. "It takes a bit. I take my time, and my partner isn't fond of it."
Stern attends the movies a great deal – 182 times the previous year – and is on a first-name basis with the theater staff, who occasionally must usher him out so they can commence sweeping the aisles. He considers it acceptable to utilize the credit sequence: "When you pay for a cinema ticket, the end titles are part of the feature."
Letterboxd's most passionate supporters give credit to the app with reviving enthusiasm around a challenged cinema sector, where output has decreased and work is scarce. (Letterboxd also possesses the type of user profile advertisers seek – its largest segment of users is aged 18 and 24, with those aged 25 to 35.)
Hype generates further excitement; much-hyped movies witness a surge of activity on Letterboxd shortly following the initial screenings. The highest-rated critique of a divisive film version – "Emily Brontë succumbed centuries ago yet this version is still the most egregious event that has ever befallen her" – has amassed more than 50,000 hearts. Another recent film generated this contrast to a rival's concert film: "the Eras Tour documentary left in the dust."
"It feels like an addiction," commented a marketing professional, a 33-year-old resident who is employed in marketing. He also prefers to write reviews in the closing scroll. "Processing what you just saw, right after you experienced it, helps with the viewing experience. It helps you grasp the key messages of a film. If it evokes a feeling of comfort, that's hardly something you recall five hours down the line."
He feels most motivated to critique a film if it was exceptionally good – or awful. Case in point: he recently watched a big-budget film. "I was actually so offended by how egregiously bad it was, that I was keen to take out my phone and assign it a half-star review," he said. (This reviewer is a more critical reviewer than some reviewers, who gave the film a more favorable review, calling it "smart and entertaining fare.")
Dakota Chester, a twenty-eight-year-old New Yorker who is in social media, watched a fantasy animated film at a local theater and lingered to draft the review ("I gave it a perfect score"). He has observed poorer etiquette: people pulling out their phones to log the movie they are actively viewing. "That action irritates me," he admitted.
One of cinema's most enduring urban legends tells of a showing of an 1896 motion picture that depicted a train entering a station. The medium was in its infancy and – in line with this largely discredited rumor – the shot of a locomotive moving right toward the camera shocked the spectators so much that people fled in terror.
Many decades later, movie theater manners can be just as problematic. Often, individuals knows how to behave in a theater these days, particularly when the lights dim: viewers take pictures of the screen, smuggle in odorous food, and, as seen during a cultural moment, at times get into outright brawls.
Some individuals have turned to social media to discuss the propriety of writing reviews in the closing scroll. When one social media user